HISD’s intervention has been a major focus for news outlets of all types since it began last June. Sometimes, that coverage has fallen short of reality. One example is the discussion of HISD’s Team Centers, which are differential learning spaces that are often housed inside libraries.
The news media misrepresented these Team Centers as “ discipline areas
” where students are punished for misbehaving. That characterization could not be further from the truth. In actuality, students look forward to earning time in Team Centers, as it is a reward for mastering lessons.
In Kappan’s recent interview with local journalists
, Houston Press reporter Margaret Downing lamented the “false narrative” surrounding the Team Centers:
“We saw in real time that the Team Centers were not just detention centers. They were there not only for a kid who was acting up but also students who had done particularly well and were given extra worksheets to do higher level work. But some members of the media — not the Houston Press — allowed that false narrative to keep going for weeks.” - Margaret Downing, Houston Press
Kappan’s story is here.
Why it matters:
The mischaracterization of HISD’s Team Centers contributed to fear and confusion that did not serve students. Rather than harm students, as the negative articles insinuated, Team Centers contributed to significant gains in academic achievement across all grades.
What they’re saying:
Sam Gonzalez Kelly from Houston Chronicle had a similar comment: “I was always very careful in all my stories when I mentioned the Team Centers, I always included the caveat that they are not solely used for detention, or discipline. I don’t think I ever used the word detention center in a story. But I saw a lot of outlets that did, especially the cable stations.”
Looking ahead:
HISD has improved tremendously in its first year of the intervention and is undoubtedly heading in the right direction. The district and students will look to continue the historic turnaround, regardless of the headlines.