TEA responded to the Spectrum News sensational story regarding allegations of wrongdoing by Third Future Schools, Superintendent Mike Miles former place of employment.
What’s new:
TEA Commissioner, Mike Morath sent a letter
to Representative Ana Hernandez confirming an active review of the allegations within the complaint, which notably excluded Houston ISD. The letter relayed the following:
-
“[The] complaint will involve a review of Midland ISD, Ector County ISD, and Austin ISD.”
-
“In all three cases, the districts engaged Third Future Schools to turn around chronically low-performing (i.e., F rated) campuses in those districts. All schools performed at the equivalent of a B within the first rating year of operation by Third Future Schools…”
-
“Information in the news story discusses administrative expenditures made by Third Future Schools in support of the academic turnaround… but no information was provided in the story related to Texas school system fund balance transfers out of state."
-
“The limited information included in the news story does not in of itself constitute evidence of a misappropriation of funds in Austin ISD, Midland ISD, or Ector ISD nor a contracting violation by any of those districts.”
Why it matters:
Despite the misleading narrative portrayed, it appears that Third Future Schools operated entirely within the bounds of Texas law. While many community members, including teachers’ unions, pounced on the opportunity to link the misappropriation of funds to Houston ISD and Mike Miles, neither HISD nor Mike Miles appears to be under TEA review.
What they are saying:
Third Future Schools is denying the fast and loose reports by Spectrum News, saying “[e}ach of our state networks oversees the funds for that state, and they do not cross from one state to the other.” Company officials also said, “[a]ll of our audits have been clean - the highest standard that can be met in public accounting.”
Go deeper:
Texas Public Charter Schools Association stated, “Third Future’s schools in Texas are 1882 partnerships, which means local ISD boards authorize them and approve all financial arrangements, including that Third Future has a designated bank account for each of its Texas school campuses specifically to prevent any comingling of funds.”
Bottom line:
Instead of focusing more attention on positive student outcomes, it appears some care more about sowing fear and spreading misinformation to distract from the ultimate goal of ensuring the next generation is safe and well-educated.